Jake Schram (Stiller) and Brian Finn (Norton) are single, successful, extremely popular guys who have been best friends since, well...forever. They are about to be reunited with their other best childhood buddy -- the feisty, lanky tomboy, Anna (Elfman). Anna has grown into a high-powered, workaholic beauty whose reentry into their lives turns this old circle of friends into a love triangle -- a very complicated one at that because Jake's a rabbi and Brian is a priest. But have faith, this gem is going to steal your heart.